Subscribe to @CruiseMates on Twitter!
For instant updates about new articles.
  08.24.2010  
 


Teri Franks and team at the Art Auction jury trial.

Judge Reverses Art Auction Jury

By Paul Motter

Last April Park West Gallery, the purveyor of "Fine Art Auctions" aboard several cruise ships, brought a defamation lawsuit against Fine Art Registry, a Phoenix-based company that registers works of art in order to establish its history. In the art world, the history of a work of art is known as its "provenance."

Fine Art Registry is not in the business if authenticating art; That is done by legal art appraisers. But Fine Art Registry knows the accepted methods of authenticating and appraising art, and they have claimed that Park West Gallery, especially in its cruise ship art auctions, does not follow those guidelines.

Park West objected to the allegations by Fine Art Registry and filed a defamation lawsuit asking for $46 million dollars in damages. The case was eventually heard by a jury trial in Michigan, the home state of Park West.

A jury of eight Michigan citizens took five and a half weeks to finally render an opinion - presumably based upon the evidence and according to the orders given by the judge. In the end the jury ruled that Fine Art Registry had not committed defamation and awarded Park West nothing. In a counterclaim filed by Fine Art Registry, alleging trademark violation under the Lanham Act by Park West Gallery, the jury agreed that Park West had created a web site that infringed on the trademark of Fine Art Registry. The jury awarded Fine Art Registry a judgment of $500,000 to be paid by Park West.

But last week, August 17, a Michigan judge, Lawrence Zatkoff, threw out that jury decision. Park West put out a press release saying "The U.S. District Court of the Eastern District of Michigan granted Park West Gallery a new trial in its defamation case against Fine Art Registry (FAR).

"We are pleased with the judge's ruling," the attorney Rodger Young, lead counsel for Park West Gallery is quoted as saying in the Park West press release. "These types of decisions are extremely rare, and the Court's decision sends a clear message about the severity of the actions of the Defendants and their Counsel."

Yes, it is extremely rare - especially in a case where the defendant is acquitted of the charges brought by the plaintiff. In a criminal case a judge is not allowed to set aside an acquittal verdict by a jury, because that would constitute double jeopardy, forbidden in our system of jurisprudence.

But this is a civil case. The judge issued a 55-page order for a new trial in which he basically nullified the entire original trial. He vacated the jury's verdict with respect to the nine claims asserted by Park West against the Fine Art Registry; essentially saying that the jury's finding that Fine Art had NOT committed defamation is no longer valid. He also threw out the $500,000 judgment in favor of Fine Art Registry in the Lanham Act counter-claim. Finally, the judge ordered a new trial on all of these claims.

Here is the odd thing about this turn of events. This judge, Lawrence Zatkoff, who just overturned every judgment the jury made was the same judge who presided over the trial. Even worse astounding; he will also be the judge on the NEW trial. The only thing different will be the jury, and you can be sure they will know nothing about the previous case.

If Lawrence Zatkoff felt the behavior of Ms. Franks was so egregious wasn't it his duty and obligation to deal with that during the trial? He does claim he tried. The press release quotes his order, " ... the misconduct of Franks and counsel for the FAR defendants was egregious, frequent and ongoing ... permeated the entire trial ... (a)nd unfortunately occurred with regularity during trial, including on both occasions that Franks testified ... Franks and counsel for the FAR Defendants not only continued to engage in such deliberate, intentional and highly and unfairly prejudicial conduct, the severity of their transgressions actually increased following the Court's March 30, 2010 comments and admonitions."

Okay, so the judge felt the defendants conduct was egregious. But he still let the trial go forward and allowed the jury to render a verdict.

Teri Franks, owner of Fine Art Registry, felt she was facing a handicap because the case was to be heard in the home district of Park West Gallery. She had to uproot and relocate to Michigan for the six-week duration. But at the same time she was glad for a jury trial. I am guessing the idea of a local judge hearing a case brought against her by such a rich and powerful local business put some fear into her. I know it would for me.

But in the end the judge got the final word anyway. The jury ruling was ignored - a waste of time and money.

At the Fine Art Registry web site Teri Franks, the owner and lead witness for Fine Art Registry says, "All we did was tell the truth. In a defamation lawsuit, the truth is the defense." That certainly makes sense to me. According to the legal statutes for defamation in Michigan Park West not only had to prove that the statements made by the Fine Art Registry were false, but that Fine Art knew the statements were false.

You can discuss this article in our CruiseMates Forums: Park West Gallery


We want your cruise reviews!

CruiseMates started publishing our readers' cruise reviews long before other web sites even thought of it. We already have thousands of reviews online, but there are never enough! CruiseMates and our sister site cruisereviews.com both want more of YOUR cruise reviews. So, please send them to us:

  • To submit a cruise review to CruiseReviews.com, please go here.

  • To submit a cruise review to CruiseMates, please go here .
 
 
hr blue bar
 
Liberty of the Seas $599
Roundtrip Miami to St. Thomas, St. Martin, San Juan and Labadee - balcony just $749
•  America's Vacation Center (866) 501-7271
CM Note: This is an excellent way to see Athens as part of a European vacation.
 
hr blue bar
 
Celebrity Onboard Credit + 50% Reduced Deposit Sale!
Book a select 6-10 Night Celebrity cruise and receive $50 onboard credit for ocean-view staterooms and above. Book a select 11+ night sailing and receive $100 onboard credit on ocean-view and above! Plus get 50% reduced deposit and FREE TRAVEL INSURANCE!!
•  Direct Line Cruises 1-800-352-8088
CM says: Great prices on this premium cruise line!
 
hr blue bar
 
7-night European Cruise $549
Norwegian Gem roundtrip Venice to Dubrovnik, Athens, Izmir (Turkey), Nauplion (Greece)
•  America's Vacation Center (866) 501-7271
CM Note: This is an excellent way to see Athens as part of a European vacation.
 
hr blue bar
 
Oasis of the Seas Fall Sailings Starting at $709 per person!
We still have a limited amount of discounted space on all Oasis of the Seas fall sailings. Prices are way below cruise line rates! Call now and receive onboard credit and FREE TRAVEL INSURANCE on most sailings!
•  Direct Line Cruises 1-800-352-8088
CM says: Oasis price drop reflected here!
 
hr blue bar
 
Carnival Miracle Balcony: $1,059 per person
Balcony cabins also available for 1/6, 1/22, & 2/23. 8 night sailings to Aruba, Curacao, Dominican Republic and Grand Turk. Insides from $669, balconies from $899. Some sailings have onboard credits. Call for prices, hundreds of dollars less than current rates.
•  Cruise Planners 1-800-561-0802
CM says: An exotic 8-night itinerary at a great price.
 
hr blue bar
 
Oceania Cruises on Sale!
Oceania Cruises: 2011 Alaska Summer Collection roundtrip San Francisco! Amenities and 2 for1 fares!
•  CRUISE MARKETPLACE 1-800-826-4333
CM says: Great cruise line on its inaugural Alaska season!
 
hr blue bar
 
7-night Mexico on Royal Caribbean $505
Mariner of the Seas - Biggest ship on the West Coast - leaves in January! See it now. Los Angeles to Cabo, Puerto Vallarta and Mazatlan.
•  America's Vacation Center (866) 501-7271
CM Note: West Coasters - do not miss this unique ship before it leave CA for good!
 
hr blue bar
 
CruiseMates Norwegian Epic Group Cruise!
Join Chef Matt Sigel's on Norwegian Epic, Halloween Cruise, Oct 30, 2010. Travel from Miami to Costa Maya, Roatan Honduras and Cozumel - 7-days
•  Cruise Planners 1-800-561-0802
CM says: From just $599 plus shipboard credit.!
 
hr blue bar
 
CruiseMates Allure Group Cruise!
Join CruiseMates on Allure of the Seas: October 2, 2011 From $779 per person.
•  Cruise Planners 1-800-561-0802
CM says: Our new Allure group cruise - lower prices!
 
hr blue bar
hr blue bar
hr blue bar
You can access all of these specials above - or go to CruiseMates' Cruise Bargains for even more!
 
hr blue bar
 
more about

CruiseMates, a popular online resource for unbiased and authoritative cruise information, features ship reviews and articles, cruise news, polls, message boards and more.

NEW YORK TIMES: "Many sites that offer reviews are selling cruises, which raises questions about impartiality. An exception is CruiseMates."

FORTUNE MAGAZINE: "The Web's best site for articles, advice, or chatting with Cruise People. Self-financed and run independently of the industry, so their opinions are impartial."

http://www.cruisemates.com

 
NEW ISSUE ONLINE NOW!
"CruiseMates Newsletter"

One of the best cruise travel newsletters anywhere! We feature cutting edge news stories you won't see anyplace else and commentary about a variety of cruise topics. Also get cruise bargain hunting tips, listings of actual cruise bargains, previews of our latest articles and news about our Cruisemates Group Cruises.

 

 
  hr blue bar  
 

We are an online, interactive CRUISE SHIP GUIDE with ship reviews, features articles, message boards and more. Recommended by: New York Times, Wall Street Journal, CNN Television, a Forbes Magazine "Best of the Web" site.

Prices listed are cruise only, per person, double occupancy and include port charges (also called non-commissionable cruise fare).

Fuel surcharges and government taxes & fees are additional unless otherwise noted. Prices are in US dollars, airfare is extra unless otherwise noted. Limited availability and restrictions may apply. Prices are subject to change without prior notice. Typographical errors may occur. Offers apply to new bookings only.

CruiseMates.com is an Internet Brands, Inc. website. Internet Brands is located at 909 North Sepulveda Blvd., 11th Floor, El Segundo, CA 90245 — This email was sent to %%#EMAIL%%. If you no longer wish to receive our emails please click here.

 
         
  © 2010 Internet Brands