I absolutely agree that Celebrity is the best!! From their appetizers, salads, soups, entrees, and desserts they truely excel!! I am a foodie and perhaps 50-60% of the cruise experience to me is the fine dining and service.
We are sailing Celebrity this summer after my last 2 cruises being on RCL and NCL. I will now appreciate the food on Celebrity even more. Looking at the speciality dining menus on NCL, I was reminded of the regular dining rooms menus on Celebrity and I didn't have to pay extra!
From my experience: 1. Celebrity
NCL had a diffeent souffle for dessert every night that was to die for......entrees were nothing special.
But then, any cruise is better than no cruise!