I think Celebrity slipped a little a couple of years ago and at that time their dinner fare was very comparable to RCCL. This year we found Celebrity to be on top again, superb beef, every meal was great. Celebrity lobsters are much larger than RCCL, and their fruit soups are fantastic. At the buffet Celebrity wins hands down over RCCL. Having said that, we love RCCL and have had great food in the DR and would gladly try them again.