Definite "Loyalist" here! Not only D+ but we were even invited to the "Top Cruisers" dinner on our South American Member's Cruise. I didn't even know such a thing existed (not the same as invitation to Captain's table in dining room). The Staff members were GREAT and it wasn't at all "stuffed shirt."
We fly to the U.K. in Sept to bring the "Jewel" back across the pond and I should hit forty cruise credits on that run. Woo-Hoo!!