I agree, it is all subjective. I'm strickly speaking about the dining room selections. I generally think all buffets are pretty much the same, none are great, but I don't expect any to be good. I'm also not speaking of pay restaurants, I hate the idea, because when you pay for the cruise, food is what you are paying for. To pay 20.00 per person, per night, that amounts to 280.00 more, certainly not a bargain when you add it in!