Thanks for the tips everyone.
I've swam with stingrays twice in Grand Cayman, I'd like to do something different this time.
LOVED Key West but didn't have nearly enough time there. Want to find something GREAT to do and buy a drink in a pineapple!
Never been to Jamaica and the Falls may be it. We'll see.
I think it may actually happen, and I AM SO EXCITED! 8 cruises later and I am still thrilled head to toe when I think about leaving on one!