Are you kidding me?
We just got back from a 10 dayon the Island Princess and it was the most restrictive cruise I have been on for a smoker like me.
Smoking on the outer decks was limited to a few tables by the Lido pool, they didn't want you to smake elsewhere on that side of the ship.
Inside the ship was a very small, 10 chair Churchills lounge to smoke in and the Casino, except there was no smoking in the casino on the fromal nights.
Thank God that I could still smoke in my room and on my balcony.
Smokers have had their rights continually taken from them. I think that it is time to stop this non-smoking madness and leave us a few places to smoke, inside and out, or the cruise industry will see many smokers leave for other, unrestrictive forms of vacationing.