I'd like to see them reward you each time you return to Carnival. Wouldn't have to be much, a little something for the 2nd, and a little bit more for the 3rd, etc. Perhaps a free dinner at one of the 'reservations only'. You'd be surprised at how a small thank you makes a person want to show their loyalty. Like you said, it feels good to simply be asked your opinion. This is our 4th coming up and I have no reason to be loyal to Carnival. I understand that the 3 and 4 day cruises can't count, but the week long + should be appreciated. There certainly are many to choose from out there.