Yes, I've done both RSVP & Atlantis. All I can say is their are simply wonderful. I've done many straight cruises and they don't even begin to compare to the all-gay charters. I've meet alot of really nice guys on the cruises. I've never found the charter to overly sexual except many in the steam room. There are all types of guys and age ranges and body types. Everyone seems very friendly and I've never found a lot of attitude. Yes, there is a lot of nice eye candy around the pool, but you'll also see bear or daddy types too! Whatever you style, age, taste you'll find it. The entertainment is always top notch. The only down side to these charter is they are at premium cost; however, I think it's well worth it given the atmosphere and entertainment. I highly recommend these charters.