Thank you all very much for the lively discussion. I think it is time to become more vocal with HAL about their smoking policy. I did not have a good experience with Celebrity therefore I do not see myself going back with them anytime soon. I did however love their stance on smoking. Here in Florida smoking has been banned in all food establishments. Many other attractions and indoor venues have banned smoking too. It is the right thing to do. It is a disgusting and poses a health risk to other passengers. The vast majority of cruises sail with a majority of non-smokers. I think we should all voice our opinions with Holland America. Leave one smoking room and ban smoking from balconies, and all other indoor venues. Thank you all for your input.