Very good scenario Eric...SB wins in this case IMO. Btw, for similar comparison we have the Mariner TA Nov 2011 booked at $314 pp (we take air credit as we use ff miles). We also have the maiden SB Quest crossing (Nov 2011) booked at $265 pp. We picked SB and will transfer or cancel our Regent booking. We did not use one free excursion two months ago on the Voyager crossing in Nov 2010--tho we paid for them. In retrospect, I like the SB pricing model over Regent..but for us, the proof will be the sailing and checking out the dining, service, and for me especially, the fitness facilities on board the Quest.