I agree with JP. What is the point of having guidlines? The lines do this to promote a certain atmosphere. The more casual the dress code, the more casual behavior is. If the reason most people choose Celebrity is their refinement compared to RCI or Carnival then why do they dress down for the occasion. Why do people want to make exceptions, is it laziness? It is not hard to pack accordingly for the recommendations. If someone is struggling with this then maybe Celebrity is not for them. There are many choices for many tastes.