Well I've had both! I've seen documentation on Barrachina too--and they both claim the same guy--so who knows. I don't think I've ever broken my record for a bar tab since I stayed at the Caribe Hilton. Great bar and location, attracted hotties from the beach, pool and hotel lobby. But that was 30 years ago and I was young and foolish. Now I'm old and hopefully a little less foolish.