I recommend Marva Shaw Tours, you can look up Marva Shaw on FB and I believe the website is knowjamaica.com...The crazies group uses Marva every time when in Jamaica, and Marva does an outstanding job of helping you see what you want in her country. Last time there on BC5, we had a large group that divided on who wanted to do what <like herding cats we are lol> so she took one group to Rose Hall and for a tour/shopping, and another group got dropped off at Dr's Cave Beach. We spent a few hours at the beach <and bar> there. We then walked a couple blocks along that main road to M'Ville and they picked us up there at the agreed time to go back. Fabulous day!!! HTH!