We all have our likes and dislikes which makes these forums fun I think. For example, you think that nightlife is important to you where the most important thing for us is scenery and itinerary. All the cruises you seem to be looking at go to Tracy arm. Well, here's my bias. Find a ship that goes to Glacier bay or Hubbard. Not that Tracy Arm's bad, just the other locations are better. You might want to look at the Norwegian Pearl from Seattle. Probably a younger crowd than Celebrity. HAL and Celebrity seem to have older crowds but in Alaska we found that not as obvious. We sailed Alaska on HAL, Celebrity, NCL, and loved all 3 (once from Seattle). Just continue to do your homework, listen to our tips and hints, and choose what you feel is best for you. You'll enjoy the honeymoon for sure. It's wonderful in Alaska.