I have mixed feelings. You must know you are not getting this for free! One way or another you will pay for these services. As long as we could opt-out of the service/package it is fine.
On Celebrity with open seating your tips are prepaid. No problem with that as you are going to do this one way or another and you can modify the amount if you wish.
I would not want to have to buy into a drink program for wine and hard liquor. That must stay the option of the guest. And if desired there should be a way for one person in the cabin to buy into it if desired. I do not drink soda, wine etc but my husband does. We now would have to buy the package for both people. Yes, I know some will take advantage of it. Always someone who will. There has to be a way for one person to buy into this alone.
I will be interested in seeing how they bundle shore excursions. Will be interesting to see how much the cruise price goes up.
Will be watching for this to see how it works.