My wife and I were on the Liberty Dec. 8-17th of 2012. In my opinon the Guys Burgers were hit and miss. We had them 3 times and 1 of the times they were not good at all..If I had to guess it was the fact that there were long lines and they were in a huge hury to get burgers off the grill.
The Aft pool area was normally pretty quiet where as the mid pool area was always hopping with live music and games etc. You MUST try the Diamond steakhouse. It is worth the extra cost!. What are your ports of call?