I can see where your coming from. In just the short time I've kind of gotten to know you your a very energetic women who loves the live music and dancing and I can say I do believe RC fits the bill for that much more than Carnival does. Carnival in my opinion is not a high energy cruise or at least the ones I've been on. While there are things going on that I find entertaining I can see how it falls short for you.
I believe you had posted something like "who cares what line just cruise" I couldn't agree more.
One more thing , my cruise partners and I all agreeded today that Allure will be our next cruised booked.