There is no need to bash other Cruise Lines.
My wife and I have sailed on Celebrity for our Honeymoon and Carnival the last 2 summers. We like both lines. Each one is different and trying to compare the two is like comparing apples and oranges. There is more Carnival bashing on this board then there is Celebrity bashing on the Carnival board. Some of you are truly snobs, and I don't mean it in the nice way. Just because Carnival doesn't give you the refined experience that Celebrity gives you, it doesn't mean that Celebrity is any better then any other line.
Sorry if this is harsh, but it's the way I feel.