> We asked them how this worked they said they had to turn
> in all of the money even the extra, they were not allowed to
> keep it. I was disappointed because I thought they could keep
> the extra money over the specified amount. From now on we will
> just use the auto-tip and slip them extra if we would like to
> during the cruise.
That is a bummer. I tip more than the suggested amount when I get very good service but I thought the extra was going to the person I was handing the money. If it isn't, that changes my idea about going above the suggested amount. I think that stinks.