Star Princess. Or Golden or Grand Princess. Caribbean Princess sounds nice , but it is just that much bigger and might seem a bit crowded to me.I would try it though before I would go on another Carnival.
Food is better on Princess, not weirder.
Carnival is " Las Vegas" rah, rah, rah, ( which of course some people like)
We took two Carnivals then in early thirties switched to Princess, whew , what a nice difference. Just our taste, but we just aren't into glitz.
Age didn't seem to matter as we see all ages on Princess.
Nice pools on Princess( open late at night, fresh water not salt like Carnival)
Your hubby will love the late night comedians, very funny ( bit rude actually) and the show we saw "Lights Camera Action" in April was great.
This is of course only our opionion and I am sure many would disagree, it isn't that we think Carnival is a " bad line" I mean we did cruise on it twice right? It's just that we really found our niche on Princess, and may be you will also.