We just got back in November from a 4 day on the Enchantment. Our first cruise was on the same ship a few years back, before the construction.
The ship is beautiful, the staff freiendly. However we chose the Enchantment again because we enjoyed Matt Baker as a cruise director. The new Director was very sociable and funny however there didn't seem to be as many pool side activities/games as before.
We didn't get lobster but the food was excellent.
They still offered the coke card.
We probly won't book on that cruise again, we will try another ship.