We have been to Hawaii 11 times and stayed on 5 islands.
The Old Lahaina Luau is truly the best we have been to. It is more traditional without all the glitz of a mass produced show. It is less crowded than some of the larger shows and the setting is absolutly beautiful. The sunset from the beach location is one you will never forget. Book now if you are even thinking about going. They sell out months in advance.
Have a wonderful time in Hawaii., Aloha