Kuki, I thoroughly enjoyed your day by day report on Liberty. We were on the 6 day cruise right after you. We had a group of 37 and at least half were newbies (four grandaughters were part of the group). This was our 20th cruise and fourth with Carnival. We liked the ship and the overall experience, but service in the Golden dining room was almost non existant. Our waiter just couldn't get it together and his assistant would disappear after the initial water was poured. Our four tables always had dessert after everyone had left on both levels of the dining room. All that aside, we all enjoyed the cruise immensely and next up is the Miracle in May.