Tracy Arm catamaran vs. Taku Lodge Floatplane

Hi Folks...I'm trying to decide between the ever popular Taku Lodge floatplane tour or a catamaran trip to Tracy Arm from Juneau...I hear both are wonderful
Ivan

[Karen16]

Unless you are going all day and up to the Sawyer glaciers in Tracy Arm- don't bother, problem is it will take most of your port day. Having done both, my clear preference is still a glaicer helicopter landing. Taku lodge doesn't even make a distant second for me.