Disney cruise vs Carnival cruise - please help

[footballmouse]

I need to help pushing me to make this decision. I've noticed the prices go up each day. We're looking to go next September (beginning), there will be 5 of us & none of us have cruised before. Here are my choices:

3 day Disney cruise & 4 days at an All-Star Resort w/4 park days or 3 park days & 1 pool day (even though the value resort's pools are about the same as our swim club pool just a little bigger).

3 day Carnival cruise & 4 days at Beach Club or Contemporary w/3 park days & 1 pool day (definately since they have awesome pools).

Price difference is about $1500 at least (Disney cruise being more).

We've been to Disney many times although our last trip was 4 yrs ago, always staying at a value resort or off-site. We'll most likely never take a trip like this again so I want to make sure I'm choosing the best one.

Thanks for any advice or help you can give.

[Paul Motter]

Does the Disney cruise includes a stay at Disney World in Orlando?

Where are these "resorts?" you are talking about?

What are the ages of the people cruising? any kids?

[Phil&Liz]

Originally Posted by Paul Motter

Does the Disney cruise includes a stay at Disney World in Orlando?

Where are these "resorts?" you are talking about?

What are the ages of the people cruising? any kids?

All the same questions I was going to ask. Need more info to make a decision.