I've done several New Years Eve cruises; and when we went with RCCL we had a great time; but we went with Carnival a year and a half ago, and they didn't even give us free champagne, as RCCL did. We felt we got our monies worth with Royal Caribbean but not with Carnival but it's a great way to spend NY Eve. I always thought the extra money was worth it. We did RCCL for the milinieum NY Eve cruise and saw their fireworks display and it was great. We'll keep doing NY Eve cruises, but just not wtih Carnival.
Carnival just tried to sell everyone bottles of champagne at midnight instead of giving out free drinks. I thought for the price of the cruise they could have given out drinks at midnight........ Happy Cruising......