Bad - REALLY CROWDED! Everywhere you went seemed to be a rat race. Dipping holes (otherwise known to man as swimming pools) were small, there are only two on Valor and they are both salt water, make no mistake, if water gets in your eyes it burns. Getting a seat by the pool was not bad, however, the kids were killing me and I think people in general really didn't care what their kids were doing. Horseback riding at St. Marteen was terrible for any horse lover.
Good - The shows were awesome, definately a must see, all of them! The food was good, not excellent, just good....If your a drinker there are many bars and clubs to do that sort of thing at. The excursions Carnival offers are fair price. I don't think we could of did any better on our own. Trunk Bay, St. Thomas was a nice excursion.
Excellent - The cabin was always kept immaculent! The beds are heavenly...Pearl Island Treasure Hunt is a must do in Nassau! Can you say SPA, 11th floor.
Let me know if you have any futher questions, be specific. If you need advice for shopping in St. Thomas, excursions, spa, food, let me know as we pretty much did it all.