having just completed the 8 day sail- just our opinion but if you are considering supper club at all "Harry's"- I'd say tues,wed or thurs. My opinion those were least favorite main dish meals.
any questions be'd happy to answer- we sailed with ourselves in 40's, my parents mid 60's and two 16 yr old boys.
We're going on the Carnival Liberty, too. The formal nights are the nights of the days at sea, which makes it Sunday & Friday nights. (When the person said 2 & 7 it might have been a little confusing).
I'm looking forward to a great time. Was to San Juan, St. Thomas & the Bahamas last year on another ship. looking forward to Antigua & Tortola. Already booked the Royal Swim with the Dolphins at dolphindiscovery.com in Tortola.