I think I asked about this a couple of years ago
, but here I am again... we still have yet to take our first cruise on Carnival, but now we have an opportunity to join a group of families in our town that are going on the Oct 6th sailing.
Keep in mind that my kids have only ever sailed Disney, and that we just got off the Magic a few days ago. (We were on the "stuck/stranded" ship that was delayed a full day.) I have also sailed RC and am very open to trying other cruise lines.
So... my specific questions are:
1) How is Half Moon Cay? Does anyone have a comparison to Castaway Cay, DCL's island? That is the only cruise ship island I have been on.
2) Anyone have kids who have been in clubs on both Carnival and DCL? My kids enjoyed the DCL clubs, some more than others. Would love to hear anything specific. My kids will be 12, 9, and 5 in October.
3) Is it hard having two days at sea in a row, twice? Our recent cruise had two days at sea, but they were separated by port days. I wonder about that second day... does the staff do everything they can to "mix things up" and keep it interesting?
4) Anyone ever done this specific cruise at this time of year? Can you tell me anything about the weather? I imagine I know what it'll be like in NY, and the first day at sea... but I'm thinking that by the second day at sea it would start to get pretty warm... ? We went to WDW in early October 08, and it was HOT. So was the Bahamas. HOT HOT HOT.
That's all for now... I appreciate any information you have! And please tell me if my questions aren't specific enough.