CruiseMates Cruise Community and Forums

CruiseMates Cruise Community and Forums (http://www.cruisemates.com/forum/)
-   Carnival Cruise Lines (http://www.cruisemates.com/forum/carnival-cruise-lines/)
-   -   Carnival or RCCL? (http://www.cruisemates.com/forum/carnival-cruise-lines/395172-carnival-rccl.html)

hpotterfan77 March 18th, 2013 12:58 PM

Carnival or RCCL?
 
My husband have been planning to book a cruise on Carnival for April of next year for our 10th anniversary however, all of these issues the last month or so with their ships has me nervous. I found a cruise with RCCL that goes to Bermuda, St. Marteen, San Juan and Labadee. I'm wondering if anyone here has been on both Carnival and RCCL and has been to all of these places. The Carnival cruise goes to the Bahamas and Grand Turk. Can someone help me out here? The price is obviously better on Carnival and we can get a balcony for the price of an inside on RCCL. Advice? Thanks! :shock:

big apple March 18th, 2013 07:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hpotterfan77 (Post 1467692)
My husband have been planning to book a cruise on Carnival for April of next year for our 10th anniversary however, all of these issues the last month or so with their ships has me nervous. I found a cruise with RCCL that goes to Bermuda, St. Marteen, San Juan and Labadee. I'm wondering if anyone here has been on both Carnival and RCCL and has been to all of these places. The Carnival cruise goes to the Bahamas and Grand Turk. Can someone help me out here? The price is obviously better on Carnival and we can get a balcony for the price of an inside on RCCL. Advice? Thanks! :shock:

Have been on both lines several times and if ports visited are important your two choices RCCL wins hands down . You have not indicated which ships are involved and this in my opinion also would influence my decision. Price is also a consideration and balcony a much better room selection. Either choice you will have fun.

Donna March 18th, 2013 09:55 PM

It would help if you mentioned what ships you are considering?? It also looks like twice the ports on the Royal Caribbean ship over the CArnival ship. Where do the ships depart from??

Trip March 18th, 2013 10:10 PM

I have been to all these ports, except Bermuda, on both cruise lines.You will get a bigger cabin on Carnival with good food on both. Some would say Carnival has better food.. I loved it, but, have no sailed RCI in a while. I have enjoyed great shows on both lines, and, would prefer not to have an inside cabin.

Are you a first time cruiser,looking for port info? Also, remember April vacation is different all over the country, so, April will have a larger kid population onboard, if that makes a difference to you...it can impact how one enjoys a cruise,when there are lots of kids.

I also feel that while at the moment Carnival is having issues, next year, it's possible it could be another line in the spotlight... I would not hesitate to book w/Carnival.

thecruisequeen March 18th, 2013 11:36 PM

Sounds like you are looking into the Explorer that does the 9 nighter with ports you mentioned in your post and Carnival Miracle.

I have done the Explorer 9 nighter and love love love that itinerary....A private island (Labadee) st. maarten, san juan and Bermuda with 4 full sea days. Usually the ships leaving out of NJ/NY that do Bermuda are 7 night bermuda cruises. With explorer you get the caribbean with bermuda. Bermuda is so beautiful...

I have not been on Miracle. I hear Turks is wonderful we finally were going to port there with Carnival Breeze but turks stop got cancelled. Bahamas I can take it or leave it...If any of my future cruises never stop at Bahamas it would be too soon. Not a fan of Bahamas.

Food wise both cruiselines were good.
Carnival has bigger cabins.
Entertainment as well as service hands down Royal.

Royal is a longer cruise then Carnival but on Carnival you get a balcony. Carnival most of the times prices out alot cheaper.

What would be more important for you in a cruise vacation....Food, entertainment, service, balcony, itinerary?

jasonfromnj March 19th, 2013 12:19 AM

Hi been on dccl explore of the sea good food big fun ship dont do carnival splendor 2 propulsion problems and is only 4 years old you may want to do ncl breakaway

hpotterfan77 March 19th, 2013 09:01 AM

Thanks
 
Ok so more info for you....lol I have never been to any of the ports with the exception of Bermuda. The one thing that bugs me about Royal is you only get 1 day in each port versus 2 days in the Bahamas and 1 day on Grand Turk. A bigger cabin sounds nice and we do spend a bit of time in them when we're just feeling plain lazy. The ship for Carnival is the Splendor though I have only heard about the engine fire on that ship a couple of years back. The Royal ship would be the Explorer. We're leaning more toward Carnival because of the fact that I can get a better room for less. I'd rather have more $ to spend on the cruise itself than paying more for a smaller room.

Jamman March 19th, 2013 09:32 AM

We have done both these intineraries several times on the Explorer of the Seas and the Carnival Miracle. We will be repeating the Grand Turk, Half Moon Cay, Nassau cruise on the Carnival Splendor this coming August. Both are GREAT cruises, but we like Carnival a bit better. A couple of opinions...

The Explorer is a much nicer ship, with a lot more amenities, which translates into higher fares. If rock climbing walls, ice skating rinks, in line skating, etc. don't mean that much to you, go for the balcony cabin on the Splendor.

Comparing the food on both lines (dining room, lido, etc), Is a very subjective subject, but we feel that Carnival is better....Hands down.

Itinerary wise, the Explorers Bermuda and Labadee, though very nice, are trumped by the Splendors Grand Turk and Half Moon Cay. The other ports on both lines, San Juan, Nassau, and St. Maarten we have been to so many times, that they are not a factor in selecting an itinerary for us.

Again, these are just our opinions. Have a GREAT cruise whichever line you finally cruise!!

Trip March 19th, 2013 10:40 AM

Grand Turk is a nice beach day...just walk off the ship, and down the pier. The beach is right there,and into the compound,there is a big pool a Margarittaville. Several shops dot the area, along with a big store of, what you find onboard the Carnoval shops, but, with many more selections.

Take a cab over to the Atlantis, and indulge in this amazing place! The Dig ,and the Aquarium are a wonderful way to spend some time, along with the casino,and the hotel shops.

The Straw Market is your bargaining place downtown,, where local crafts people sell their wares, and the prettiest shop in the Caribbean is John Bull, right there, to make you drool, with leather goods, perfumes and baubles.

I really enjoy Nassau

jasonfromnj March 19th, 2013 12:19 PM

look into who own the island and who own and runs the port more that half the time the cruise line

Aerogirl March 19th, 2013 02:36 PM

I agree with most above, I think you will have a great time on either ship so
just pick the one that's most appealing to you and your needs.
The one thing we really like about Carnival is the room size.

hpotterfan77 March 20th, 2013 09:10 AM

Thank you to everyone for the advice. We have decided to book with Carnival. Just seems to make more sense to us...lol

Aerogirl March 20th, 2013 11:13 AM

Congrats.....let the fun begin!

twoAlaskans March 20th, 2013 11:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hpotterfan77 (Post 1467866)
Thank you to everyone for the advice. We have decided to book with Carnival. Just seems to make more sense to us...lol

Congrates...have fun, and I hope you all enjoy the trip! we have only been on one cruise before and loved it, loved the balcony we had on the Conquest and loved the food and experience and customer service on Conquest...we would also suggest the Steakhouse the night of your Anniversary we did it for our 20th (we were on the ship) and it was a wonderful experience worth every bit of the 70 bucks for both of us...the steakhouse is akin to a ruth crist and let me tell you the steaks, service, the entire meal WOW....the balcony, wife and I would enjoy sunsets or rises depending on what direction we were headed and enjoyed the dauphins swimming with the ship we spent hours enjoying the sea on the balcony...and we told ourselves we would never sail again unless in a balcony after seeing the inside cabins, we just could not do it...but I am sure there are those who enjoy them...but we enjoyed our balcony...room service for breakfast sitting on the balcony...let me tell you was a wonderful experience...

hpotterfan77 March 20th, 2013 01:22 PM

Thank you
 
We're actually going the month after our actual anniversary. We had to plan that way because of our kids. They aren't coming with us but we needed someone to watch them the week of their spring break...lol

jasonfromnj March 21st, 2013 02:52 AM

any thing but carnival own ship it the best way 2 go

twoAlaskans March 21st, 2013 11:21 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jasonfromnj (Post 1467971)
any thing but carnival own ship it the best way 2 go

Troll much...every post you make is anti what ever and with the worse grammar ever

jasonfromnj March 21st, 2013 11:24 AM

its Not a spelling B

hpotterfan77 March 21st, 2013 11:31 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jasonfromnj (Post 1468009)
its Not a spelling B

Perhaps not but A. You are doing nothing but bashing Carnival and B. What's the point of commenting on posts if you can't spell or write a clear sentence that anyone else but yourself can understand?

Aerogirl March 21st, 2013 11:45 AM

Hpotterfan77
Rest assure your going to have a great time, no worries my friend.

hpotterfan77 March 21st, 2013 11:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Aerogirl (Post 1468014)
Hpotterfan77
Rest assure your going to have a great time, no worries my friend.

Thanks! I know I will. Like I said somewhere before, by the time it's our turn next year to get on, I'm fairly certainly Carnival will have inspected and fixed the issues on their ships.

S.S.Oceanlover March 23rd, 2013 07:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hpotterfan77 (Post 1467766)
Ok so more info for you....lol I have never been to any of the ports with the exception of Bermuda. The one thing that bugs me about Royal is you only get 1 day in each port versus 2 days in the Bahamas and 1 day on Grand Turk. A bigger cabin sounds nice and we do spend a bit of time in them when we're just feeling plain lazy. The ship for Carnival is the Splendor though I have only heard about the engine fire on that ship a couple of years back. The Royal ship would be the Explorer. We're leaning more toward Carnival because of the fact that I can get a better room for less. I'd rather have more $ to spend on the cruise itself than paying more for a smaller room.

What in your opinion is so much better about being in the Bahamas 2 days as opposed to being at a port for 1 day?

Most people would rather be anywhere but the Bahamas.

I see you have already picked where you will be going but I'm just curious.

I am sure you will enjoy the Splendor.

Bill

big apple March 23rd, 2013 06:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by S.S.Oceanlover (Post 1468197)
What in your opinion is so much better about being in the Bahamas 2 days as opposed to being at a port for 1 day?

Most people would rather be anywhere but the Bahamas.

I see you have already picked where you will be going but I'm just curious.

I am sure you will enjoy the Splendor.

Bill

Totally agree with you as the Bahamas certainly not like when we first visited in the late 50,s and early 60,s. Paradise Island was an island only with no hotels and you took a small boat for a wonderful day at a beautiful beach and at night went over the hill to some very lively bars when the limbo was just starting by the original Sweet Richard and Princess Kitty. No McDonalds and the country was run by the British.Fancy rum drinks only a dollar and the British colonial was the place to be for the more affluent. Now in my opinion nothing but a tourist trap and very expensive if you travel to the Atlantis Hotel for anything connected to this gambling mecca.

hpotterfan77 March 25th, 2013 08:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by S.S.Oceanlover (Post 1468197)
What in your opinion is so much better about being in the Bahamas 2 days as opposed to being at a port for 1 day?

Most people would rather be anywhere but the Bahamas.

I see you have already picked where you will be going but I'm just curious.

I am sure you will enjoy the Splendor.

Bill

Honestly, I've never been to the Bahamas so being able to spend a couple of days there sounds nice...lol

Manuel March 25th, 2013 09:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jasonfromnj (Post 1468009)
its Not a spelling B

Yes it isn't. Which is good thing. LOL

TM

skymaster March 25th, 2013 09:10 AM

I too, think you made the correct decision. Put the extra money in your pocket, and enjoy that larger cabin. It's gonna be a GREAT cruise!

"SKY"

storybookcruises.com March 25th, 2013 06:28 PM

We've been on both many times and always prefer RCCL over Carnival no matter the ship we've gone on. But that's us. Keep in mind that what one person loves, another will hate.

This goes for the food, too. Some people prefer McDonalds, while others prefer Burger King, yet others like both, and others don't like either. Food is very subjective and everyone's taste is different.

But why only thing about RCCL and Carnival? Why not consider some other cruise lines?

Often you can get better without spending more money. So you have to ask yourself what's more important to you; money, food, quality, ship, itinerary, etc?

Talk with your agent (don't book directly with the cruise line or online) and have them present several options to you. You might be surprised as to what you may find. But it's important for you to find the right cruise for you based on your requirements, budget, and lifestyle.

Pete

hpotterfan77 March 26th, 2013 09:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cruise planner (Post 1468408)
We've been on both many times and always prefer RCCL over Carnival no matter the ship we've gone on. But that's us. Keep in mind that what one person loves, another will hate.

This goes for the food, too. Some people prefer McDonalds, while others prefer Burger King, yet others like both, and others don't like either. Food is very subjective and everyone's taste is different.

But why only thing about RCCL and Carnival? Why not consider some other cruise lines?

Often you can get better without spending more money. So you have to ask yourself what's more important to you; money, food, quality, ship, itinerary, etc?

Talk with your agent (don't book directly with the cruise line or online) and have them present several options to you. You might be surprised as to what you may find. But it's important for you to find the right cruise for you based on your requirements, budget, and lifestyle.

Pete

Actually, it's a matter of the departure port. We prefer to go out of New York and not all ships go out of New York and New Jersey so it's a matter of convenience for us.

storybookcruises.com March 26th, 2013 08:10 PM

You still have a choice of cruise lines other than RCCL and Carnival.

Princess, Holland America, and Celebrity all go out of the area, so there are definitely other choices. All depends on where you want to go, when, and how much you want to spend.

Pete


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 11:16 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7 Beta 1
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.6.1