Barb:
1. You can buy any liquor you want in any port, bring it on board and drink it in your room. I don't think you can buy wine in port and bring it to dinner room. You have to buy theirs.
2. There is a minibar/refregirator in the room. It's locked. I think you need to ask for a key. We had a baby with us, so out room attendant opened it for us so we could store milk in there.
3. I am not sure about differences in 1c vs 2c. If you look in the brochure, it can tell you if there are any differences. Celebrity web site has the same info.
4.Not sure about the butler. He/She might be there is you want to shcedule a party, book an excursion or need anything and don't want to do it yourself.
5.There is no fee to use a fitness room. It has all the latest steppers, walkers and bikes (both uppers and lower). It has also the weight equipment and free weights. They also have a sceduled stepping classes. Every time I was there is was not buisy. I think you have an option to sigh up for a time for a walkers.
6. Catolina is an island that has a beach only. I think they had a Golf excursion on Casa De Campo. Check the Celebrity website.
7.Not sure about $5 blackjacks. With the 2 year old, we did not get a chance to gamble.
8. Not sure about the Cinnema. Entertainment was OK. It's pretty similar to other Cruise lines. My oppinion.
Hope that helps.
ES