Though reasonably well-traveled I've never been on a cruise, and my husband & I are considering these two ships for similar cruises on the Caribbean in February 2004. Ideally we'd love the ability to escape any smokers' fumes, great service, excellent room soundproofing, and very few children on the cruise (we have a new baby - you know how that goes), a late-night disco, a jacuzzi/hot tub open late, and a great spa and workout area ... does anyone have an opinion comparing the two ships for these attributes, or can anyone tell me about any of the above on either of these two ships?
Thanks so much,
Marlo