Sailed her the last 2 Aprils. Gorgeous ship, food will be OK entertainment is weak. Having said that the pricing is usually very good and we had a great time even with Costa having gone closer to the way of Carnival who now owns her. At night look for options besides some of the shows as we did. The disco is one of the nicest we have enjoyed on a cruise if you have interests in that area. Once complaint is during spring break they allow teens and preteens to take total control of the disco.
I sailed on the Atlantica this past Jan. The ship is not as elegant as some ships I have been on. Lots of glitz and a carnival or Las Vegas type atmosphere. The colors in the cabin are bright orange and green, and a little hard on the eyes. Food and service was good and you can't beat it for the money.