CruiseMates Cruise Community and Forums

CruiseMates Cruise Community and Forums (
-   Cruise Cuisine (
-   -   Dining Comparisons (

pinecone November 30th, 2003 11:12 AM

Dining Comparisons
The one thing I look forward to most on ships is the dining experience. I have been impressed with Carnival recently, as their food quality on their newer ships now is on par with many other lines in my opinion.

I am ready to book my next cruise, and would be willing to try new lines. I can not afford the "high end" lines, so they will not be considered.

Of the lines rated below, please respond by ranking in order from best to worst the quality of food in the main dining room. Please do not list any line for which you have not sailed in the past five years.

Thanks for your replies.

--Royal Caribbean
--Holland America

Lisa November 30th, 2003 03:07 PM

Re: Dining Comparisons
In order of those I have been on:

Celebrity, Princess and Carnival.

mkhilloo November 30th, 2003 08:20 PM

Re: Dining Comparisons
royal caribbean, princess, carnival

mbuckellew December 1st, 2003 12:34 PM

Re: Dining Comparisons
I have only been on Carnival and Celebrity, but found the dining experience and cuisine far superior on Celebrity.

Michelle B.

christine fischer December 3rd, 2003 11:44 AM

Re: Dining Comparisons
My experience says: celebrity, carnival, norweigan but all three were very good! Celebrity's is slightly more upscale. Although I like to think of myself as at least a little sophisticated, sometimes I didn't know what items were and would have to ask the waiter. Also, they have truly fabulous homemade deserts, breads pastries and ice cream. By comparison, on Carnival I found these types of items only passable - I wouldn't bother with them reasoning that I'd rather have the yummier items take up space in my tummy and add to my calorie count!
I have had better food at very expensive restaurants (the truly extraordinary ones) but each of these lines offered fare that was as good as most expensive restaurants.
You will not go hungry.

cathy December 6th, 2003 01:37 PM

Re: Dining Comparisons
I have only been on Celebrity and Royal Caribbean.

1st choice: Celebrity (every dining room meal was great)

2nd choice: Royal Caribbean (Explorer was okay, Brilliance not so great.....weird spices in their dishes)

On any ship, try the specialty restaurants, they are worth the money.

I'm going on the Summit next week, I'm sure the food will be great. I'm also going on the Jewel of the Seas next year and it will be interesting to see if the food is the same as the Brilliance) I hope not, I hope they've improved their recipes.

Chuck Palm December 8th, 2003 08:20 PM

Re: Re: Dining Comparisons
I think it varies more by ship than by line. As an example, last summer on the Amsterdam the food was awful most of the time. Two weeks ago on the Veendam the food was outstanding. Go figure...

Celebrity, Princess, and H.A.L. usually do a fair job, but none of these lines is flawlwss, by far.

JOE REYNOLDS December 9th, 2003 09:34 PM

Re: Dining Comparisons
I have been on Celebrity, Carnival and Royal Caribbean.
Food on Carnival is up with the best I think in the main dining room. Carnival also has pizza 24 hrs a day. I like Celebrity mostly because of the cabins. Royal caribbian food was not any better than Carnival in the Dining room
Carnival ships sailed- the old Carnivale, Paradise, and Holiday
Celebrity-- Milennium, Infinity,Constellation, Summit, and Horizon.
RCI- Monarch of Seas, Splendour of Seas
Now I am not mentioning the speciality restaurants on the Celebrity ships. Nothing can be as good as that, but the main dining room on Celebrity is not any better than on Carnival at least as of last July.

mjmiller December 17th, 2003 04:25 PM

Re: Dining Comparisons
Between Carnival and Princess- We liked Carnival more. There are more menu items I want to try on Carnival, items are less gourmet on Carnival, and overall quality was better on Carnival. Carnival has great pizza, and you can get it by the slice, whereas you cannot on Princess. I also don't like the late night lido service on Princess, where you can't just grab your own food.

Joeinwpb December 17th, 2003 10:01 PM

Re: Re: Dining Comparisons
Dinning experience is a lot more than good food and service. Dining room experience should be measured by “How much did I enjoy the it”. My best experiences have been with RCL. Not only was the food excellent, but the employees seemed to be trained to entertain, and socialize with the patrons. They’re happy, capable, and seek to make each dinning experience an unforgettable one.

I’ll be sailing on Hal this April, for the first time. I expect great food, excellent service, in an elegant setting. But I find it very difficult to believe I could have a more enjoyable time than the ones I’ve had on RCL. I’ll be expecting to have room service, and eating on the balcony, on HAL. Breakfast al fresco on the balcony won’t be hard to take.

All the people at our table (friends we met, while dining on the previous RCL cruise) Looked forward to the next dining adventure.

Also everyone I met on RCL cruises was always pleasant, and well behaved. The spirit is infectious.

alisonr December 21st, 2003 02:31 PM

Re: Re: Re: Dining Comparisons
1. Celebrity
2. Disney
3. Princess
4. Costa

marvholly December 25th, 2003 07:42 PM

Re: Dining Comparisons
I have posted on this topic on this forum and the NCL forum within the last half hour. I did not discuss Celebrity however. We sailed the Mercury to Alaska 6/1/03 and found the food very disapointing after reading all the great reviews and the Celebrity forum for months after cruises with Carnival 12/99, 12/01 and NCL 11/03. That said: I have never had totally bad food, some is better than others and if i don't have to plan, shop, cook and clean up I am a happy camper.

All times are GMT -4. The time now is 03:08 AM.

Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.6.1