Go Back   CruiseMates Cruise Community and Forums > Other Cruise Lines > Crystal
Register Forgot Password?

LinkBack Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
  #1 (permalink)  
Old August 17th, 2003, 08:27 AM
Adam Francis
Posts: n/a
Default Crystal Serenity Review

Below is a review of Crystal Serenity .I just returned from her 3rd voyage. I evaluated the vessel based on a point system, and then wrote a review on it. I am going to post it on cruise review sites soon.

Deutsch Fliegen Boot Gruppe
Eine Teilung von Deutsche Lufthansbot Groupe

GRADING RUBRIC: (actual points achieved/possible number of points)
Cuisine- 2,798/3,000
Service- 2,823/3,000
Accommodations- 1,634/2,000
Entertainment- 712/1,000
Ship- 892/1,000

TOTAL: (actual points achieved/possible number of points)
M/S Crystal Serenity- 8,859/10,000

M/S Crystal Serenity- * * * * *

HOW THE GRADING WORKS (updated official system):
* * * * * * 9,000+
* * * * * 8,500-8,999
* * * * + 8,000-8,499
* * * * 7,500-7,999
* * * + 7,000-7,499
* * * 6,500-6,999
* * + 6,000-6,499
* * 5,500-5,999
* < 5,499
__________________________________________________ __________________

Crystal Dining Room- The cuisine that is served in the Crystal Dining Room is consistently far above the standards of that found on almost every cruise line. The menu is clearly laid out and the cuisine is presented in the light classical-French tradition. The ingredients used are of an extremely high-quality and the dishes are attractively presented, although not at all gourmet. One must be aware of the extremely high noise-levels in this restaurant. This complimented with the wait-staff constantly dropping plates and silverware creates little or no ambiance at all. The service from the European staff is very good, although not always personal. Often, dishes do not come out the way one orders them. The wine list is, however, simply superb.

Prego and Silk Road- The two specialty restaurants onboard offer attractively-presented gourmet cuisine. Prego offers gourmet Italian dishes, although to some people, the food may be “deep”; most people are used to the “light” Italian side. Silk Road, the Japanese alternative dining selection on Serenity, is managed by famous Chef Nobu Matsuhisa, creator of the Nobu restaurants in London and New York. Silk Road features a wide variety of sushi, which are constantly being flown in to the ship to ensure freshness and quality. Overall, Silk Road offers extremely good value, as it is very easy to eat yourself into hundreds of dollars at the actual restaurants.

Weak points:
Dining in the Crystal Dining Room is unfortunately, not a “six-star” event, as is touted in the company’s brochures. Because of the rather small size of the dining room, and the extremely low ceilings, this creates, literally “surround-sound” loudness that is really quite deafening to the ears. Also, having to send in a filet mignon 3-4 times in order to receive “medium-rare” is really unacceptable on a ship of this class and price. At times, you get a sense that further organization with regards to the service is needed. Service at Prego can be over-the-top (such as the same waiter asking for water 3 times within a minute). At Silk Road, attentiveness is somewhat lacking at times.

__________________________________________________ __________________

Service on Serenity resembles that of a Four-Seasons, or Ritz-Carlton; attentive, yet at the same time, discrete if deemed necessary. The Filipino staff members truly make the cruise memorable; a genuine smile and feeling of constant happiness can always be seen from them. Without a doubt, the Filipino’s are a great asset to this cruise line; they are not at all an “expense”. Housekeeping is good at their job; although they sometimes do not clearly understand the connection between “keep” and “throw-away”. Front desk is extremely helpful. Butler service is superb. One will not encounter any rude staff members onboard a ship of this prestige. The word “no” should not be in any of the crew, staff, and officers vocabulary. No matter what the request is, the staff onboard does it, in style. The service onboard Serenity is definitely one of the high-points of the ship.

Weak points:
Not available

__________________________________________________ __________________

The accommodations offered onboard Serenity range from the outdoor cabins (Crystal does not offer inside cabins on Serenity) to the opulent Crystal Penthouse. As an added treat, Penthouse-accommodation guests receive many complimentary liquors, as well as 24-hour butler service. Penthouse-category suites also include a Bang & Oluffsen stereo, and a 30-inch LCD Panasonic TV display. Fresh fruit is brought into the rooms daily, and “afternoon snacks” can be brought in upon request to the butler. The “Penthouse Stateroom” does not deserve this title. They are really just overpriced staterooms with some small added amenities that one finds in the other Penthouse grades of accommodation.

Weak points:
Unfortunately, when a guest enters his or her room, they will likely find that their rooms are indeed smaller than anticipated. Thus, making it difficult to order room service as the line boasts. The bathrooms on the standard cabins are poorly-designed, which creates a rather uncomfortable, cramped experience. Older guests should note that the bathtub and shower are combined, making it difficult for anyone with a leg injury to step into the shower. This is unacceptable for a line of this standard. Another poorly-designed feature in all rooms is the fact that light can seep through the two-layers of blinds. With this in mind, how can this ship sail to Alaska (let alone another northern port-of-call) where light is seen 21 out of the 24 hours of the day? As a result, this leads a “bad night’s sleep”, especially after a long day of touring.

__________________________________________________ __________________

The entertainment offered onboard Serenity really illustrates to us the type of crowd that Crystal Cruises markets towards. This can be clearly seen on certain nights, where you are often treated to traditional musical classics. To many, this brings back old, fond memories of their life. The production shows are quite simply poor. There are no “sets”, and the shows are certainly not entertaining. Many passengers agree. The Galaxy Theatre is very small, but has excellent sight lines. In the evening, you are treated to live music throughout the vessel and in most public rooms. The Crystal Piano located in the Crystal Cove is truly a sight to see. There are also a variety of sophisticated guest entertainers from pianists to comedians. On sea days, there are a variety of guest lecturers that many find informative. Depending on your age and background, you may enjoy the entertainment to a different degree. This is reflected in the entertainment rating.

Weak points:
The Galaxy Theatre has little ambiance, and is only one deck. Often, the same music plays again, and again in the buffet. For most, this is bothersome. Depending on your age and background, you may enjoy the entertainment to a different degree. This is reflected in the entertainment rating. On sea days and when the ship is in port, there are announcements in the morning around 9 A.M. Many people are trying to sleep at this hour, and it is very disturbing to them.

__________________________________________________ __________________

Crystal Serenity is a handsome vessel with a nicely raked-bow. Many guests will be disappointed with the “apartment-block” look that she boasts from the exterior. The vessel as a whole is designed very well, with good passenger flow. The breakup of the decks is as follows:
Deck 4: Tender Embarkation Area.
Deck 5: Crystal Plaza, Crystal Cove and Crystal Dining Room. This area is magnificent with a solid glass grand piano in the center of it.
Deck 6: Caesars Palace at Sea Casino is located here. This classic casino is operated by Park-Place Entertainment. On this deck there is also the Avenue of the Stars “shopping gallery”. This area is very small, and does not belong here. The selection in the shops is extremely disappointing. Across from the shops is “The Bistro”, a very elegant area to get snacks throughout the day. The front of Deck 6 is the home to the Galaxy Theatre, the ships main show lounge. This theatre cannot compare to the theatres on newer, larger vessels in terms of technology and overall ambiance. Towards the aft of deck 6 is the Hollywood Theatre; a cinema. It is well designed, with raised seats so every seat is the best seat in the house. The photo-gallery runs along-side with the Hollywood Theatre. Behind this area is the Connoisseur Club and the Avenue Saloon. These are two of the finest public rooms at sea today in terms of décor and comfort. The aft of deck 6 boasts the “Stardust Lounge” and “Pulse”. Both are evening lounges for dancing, and music. Stardust Lounge also serves as a secondary theatre. Pulse caters to a younger crowd of people.
Deck 7: Deck 7 contains the Library, Bridge Room, “Computer University at Sea”, Prego, and Silk Road. Also on deck seven are some standard staterooms with no balconies. The Library is elegantly furnished with a wide selection of various reading materials. The Bridge Room serves it purpose well. Prego and Silk Road are both excellent.
Decks 8, 9: Standard staterooms with balconies.
Decks 10, 11: Penthouse staterooms and suites.
Deck 12: This deck is home to the Lido Café, Tastes, Trident Grill, two pools (one indoor and one outdoor), and Palm Court. The Lido Café, Tastes, and the Trident Grill can really be classified as one eatery. This area serves well-prepared food for all three meals. The selection is outstanding. The service is even better. Often, there are themed buffets for lunch which are quite creative. One pool is inside, and one is outside. Both are larger than the industry standard; and both are heated to perfection (about 86 degrees Fahrenheit). The outside one is salt-water, and the inside one is not. Palm Court is an elegant lounge where the Captains Welcome Party is held. It is also used for afternoon tea, art auctions, and a casually-elegant evening lounge. Fantasia, the children’s play-room is also on this deck. It is small, and really pointless.
Deck 13: On deck 13 one finds the paddle tennis courts, and the Crystal Spa and Gymnasium. The Spa/Gymnasium is larger than the standard of what would be found on most vessels of this class and size. The paddle tennis courts are underused, but certainly do belong there as nothing else is there.
Overall, the Crystal Serenity is a beautiful vessel with some of the finest interiors found at sea today.
Weak points:
The “Computer University at Sea” is PATHETIC!!! This center deserves to be boycotted for its OUTSTANTDINGLY HIGH prices. This is one of the main reasons that this ship is only 5-stars, not 6. The ship itself would have received a nearly perfect rating if not for this. If you search the internet on normal pages for 15 minutes, YOU WILL BE CHARGED OVER $60.00. This center needs to go. It needs to SHAPE UP OR SHIP OUT!

__________________________________________________ __________________

Overall Ending Impressions:
We at the Deutsche Lufthansbot Groupe believe that Crystal Serenity is the finest large cruise ship in service today. We wish her many pleasant cruises ahead...
Reply With Quote
Sponsored Links
  #2 (permalink)  
Old August 17th, 2003, 12:04 PM
Senior Member
First Mate
Join Date: Nov 2002
Posts: 397
Default Re: Crystal Serenity Review

Thanks for the review. It was very thorough and detailed. Is your point system based on a standardized checklist? Given the number and nature of the Weak points you mention, I am surprised you gave the ship a high overall rating. You make it sound less impressive than some Holland America ships I've sailed.


MV Discovery, South Pacific Total Eclipse Cruise
Reply With Quote
  #3 (permalink)  
Old August 17th, 2003, 03:00 PM
Adam Francis
Posts: n/a
Default Re: Re: Crystal Serenity Review

The Hotel Director of Crystal Serenity actually requested that I tell him some of the weak points. Instead of dinner, I just wrote this review and gave it to him. It is an excellent ship, despite some of the remarks I said. It far surpasses HAL and Celebrity.

Reply With Quote
  #4 (permalink)  
Old August 21st, 2003, 04:49 PM
Posts: n/a
Default Re: Crystal Serenity Review

Just to let everyone know, this review is by an individual cruiser and not by any formal or professional organization. The heading of the review and the end of the review allows an individual to assume that the poster is a part of some organization called "Deutche Lufthansbot Groupe" which is actually comprised of the poster and "sometimes a friend" who's families sometimes cruise together. I just didn't want anyone to be mislead to thinking that this post is some sort of professional reviewing organization. He admitted such on another board when questioned about this "Groupe" he professes to be a part of.

As such, this review should be taken as an individual's opinion and it's not in any way based on any professional criteria.

That said, the review is well written and balanced.
Reply With Quote
  #5 (permalink)  
Old August 22nd, 2003, 01:44 PM
Adam Francis
Posts: n/a
Default Re: Re: Crystal Serenity Review

This is a review IS from an organization. It is an organization called Deutsch Fliegen Boot Gruppe (German Fly-Boat Group) that myself and my friend are members of. We rate cruise ships. We have rated over 10. We will soon be creating a website where exclusively our reviews are posted.

Just remember, Crystal Serenity is a 5-star ship. It is not at all a bad vessel. It is the FINEST large ship at sea today.

Adam Francis

Celebrity Galaxy- 7/98
Celebrity Zenith- 7/99
Rhapsody of the Seas- 12/99
Voyager of the Seas- 8/00
Celebrity Millennium- 6/01
Radiance of the Seas- 10/01
Explorer of the Seas- 12/01
Celebrity Millennium- 4/02
Celebrity Constellation- 6/02
Celebrity Summit- 8/02
Radiance of the Seas- 8/02
Norwegian Star- 11/02
Norwegian Dawn- 12/02
Celebrity Infinity- 4/03
Radisson Seven Seas Voyager- 6/03
Crystal Serenity- 8/03
Monarch of the Seas- 10/03
Serenade of the Seas- 11/03
Mariner of the Seas- 12/03
Queen Mary II- 6/04
Reply With Quote
  #6 (permalink)  
Old August 22nd, 2003, 07:47 PM
Paul Motter's Avatar
Join Date: Aug 2000
Location: in my office!
Posts: 11,010
Send a message via AIM to Paul Motter
Default Re: Crystal Serenity Review

Thanks for your reviews. Since you are attempting to create a whole catalog of cruise reviews, one thing you might want to keep in mind that it is better not generalize about what people will like. Just because someone is older, or not older, it does not necessarily mean they will like or not like a specific style of entertainment. It might do better to describe the entertainment in more detail, and try to avoid drawing conclusions about who might like it.

Just a suggestion. Thanks for the thorough review. I hope you also submitted it to our reader reviews area.

Reply With Quote


rubric, waitstaff

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
CRYSTAL SERENITY alf1052 Crystal 5 May 25th, 2009 02:06 PM
"Crystal Serenity" Photo Review published ruderhaus Crystal 2 January 20th, 2005 09:20 AM
The Crystal Serenity Julien A Chit - Chat for Cruisers 0 March 25th, 2004 12:26 AM
Crystal Serenity 12/22 Robb Singles 1 December 13th, 2003 09:54 PM
Crystal Serenity Review Adam Francis Chit - Chat for Cruisers 0 August 17th, 2003 08:26 AM

Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 09:52 PM.
design by: Themes by Design

Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.6.1