NJMatt,
We sailed QM2 in July 2004, adored the ship but there were definitely some service issues particularly in the Britannia Restaurant. We returned this past March 9, 2005 for an 8-day Caribbean Voyage and I was very pleased to experience a 360-degree turnaround in all of the service areas.
The Britannia service was top notch, very attentive. I also felt the quality of the food had greatly improved and ranked on a close par with the standard in Caronia aboard QE2. The Golden Lion Pub was a great alternative for lunch and equally fine service. Kings Court is still a bit chaotic especially during peak hours. However, there is talk this lido area will be refurbished during the QM2's refit in November.
The ship has been streamlined in all facets, the staff is very friendly. I think you would be very pleased should you decide to return for a QM2 Voyage. We can barely wait to be back aboard this fabulous vessel on January 3, 2006.
Cruiserking