Our first cruise, we missed out on Half Moon Cay because of weather. We didn't know what we were missing so we weren't too upset, but many people were. Our second cruise, we went there and THEN we knew what we had missed the first cruise! Wow...we had such a marvelous day, we didn't want to leave. I think we waited til the last few minutes to finally head back toward the ship. We rented a clamshell, which was handy, but I think the cabana would be sooo much nicer! If you can afford it, go for the cabana!