I haven't been on your ship but on other mid-size ships in the fleet (as well as some others) so only can speak to those:
Yes on the traditional formal nights the cruisers really do dress up (about 60% best guess) and usually go to the Captains greeting prior to dinner, the sequins and jewels on the ladies are blinding. A man can get away with a sports jacket if just doing dinner but usually a tux if going to the pre affair. My son has done it both ways with renting a tux for the cruise which was quite reasonable, fit well and looked good. I myself have never done the full dress up but a skirt, nice sundress with jacket or paloozo type pants will work. If you do go all out, it is a good opportunity to get professional portraits done at a reasonable cost.
From the video of your ship it looks like the same gym - decent and free. The spa is an extra cost, the last one I was on had just been revamped with a huge whirlpool compared to your ships (via online video). I believe it worked out to about $10 a day (you have to buy for the full time though) but we got it the first day when the 50% off special was on so if that is something you are looking for then you should go there upon boarding and sign up as they also limit the number of people they allow and the price goes up. The sauna/steamrooms had in the past been used by my son without purchasing the spa package but not sure if that works anymore because they gave us a different key to access the spa area this past summer which is also where the lockers, sauna and steamrooms were located. The private relaxation area (outside with a pool) I believe was $5 - 10 a day (again you have to purchase it for the full length of the cruise) I have never bothered to use it because I only go on cruises with limited at sea days and therefore was off the ship during the day so it didn't make sense. Also since HAL usually has a minimum number of kids on board compared to some other lines and they have a seperate area for them anyway you can usually find quiet corners without having to pay extra.
I have gone on HAL pre and post Carnival did not notice a change in the service (which has always been excellent) but did notice that there were a few more "extra" costs which use to be freebees.
The tradition midnight buffet is actually at 11:00 (sometimes 10:30 so check your daily HAL) although the selection isn't huge the quality is very good and there is usually pizza and some desserts until the wee hours, as well you can order room service 24 hrs a day with a good selection and it is one of the few lines where you can still get a full breakfast cooked to order brought to your room.
As to the after dinner entertainment I think it is hit or miss (my mother in her 70's always loved it), the brought in talent has always been excellent but the shows put on by the onboard staff (musicals) tend to be things from 30's to 50's although a couple of years ago they did a Grease take off which to them was very modern so ...... mind you they are very talented singers and dancers so if you like classics then you are ok there, plus they do have piano bars and movies if you aren't into those.
I have always found HAL to be a great line, partly I believe because of the larger portion of an older crowd which tends to demand a better level of service, are polite rather than pushy or snobby and have never witness a scene or obnoxious drunk which you can find on some other lines. Have a great time!
I would just like some feedback on HAL as it is our first time on this line. We will be traveling on the Ryndam.
I know that HAL is an older crowd and this is fine with us, we like to relax and prefer the traditional cruise experience.
Does HAL still offer the "traditional"? Are there really formal nights? Do men where tuxes?
The Ryndam is older, Do they have a descent gym and spa? Are there steam room and locker room? Are they free? There is a relaxation area, cost?
HAL is now owned by Carnival . Does HAL still have good service?
Are there old fashioned "midnight Buffets?"
Is the entertainment good? Thanks, Jimbo
I have cruised on HAL 4 times in the past 4 years .Its my favorite cruise line . I was on the Volendam ,Zuiderdam and twice on the Veendam. There are 2 formal nights on a 7 day cruise and 3 on a 10 day . Service was fantastic as was the food .No midnight buffets but they had 10PM to 11PM chocolate extravaganzas ,
We love Holland America and have sailed on them around 78 nights, if my count is right. They have always provided wonderful experience. We were just on the Noordam in December and it was great.
Keep in mind that the smaller ships, like the Ryndam are not something that some people like. But with that said, what one person loves, another will hate. Personally, we love the classic smaller older ships. They offer a more intimate experience than the larger newer ships.
But don't worry too much about what people say. It's what you like that matters most.
__________________ 45 Cruises & Counting! Favorites: Paul Gauguin to Tahiti: Uniworld River Cruises in Europe; any of the Celebrity Solstice-class ships; Holland America for 12-nights in the Baltics & Russia; RCCL for 14-night Greek Isles, Turkey, & Croatia; Holland America for 14-day Alaska cruisetour; 10-night Canada/New England cruise; 21 days in Hawaii including a 7-night NCL cruise; Oceania for 25 days in Asia; & 3 months touring Europe by train. And many days spent in all-inclusive resorts!