I would certainly take the Caribe balcony. That is, if you spend a lot of time on the balcony, as we do. It's half covered, and much larger than any other balcony. Of course, that's my opinion. You may get other opinions that will disagree. The final decision will be up to you. But we just love Caribe!
Ahh, but it is the second cabin from the bow, is that near where the ancorhe chain drops( noisey) and are those cabin balconies curved in( there fore smaller?) . Keep asking , it may or may not be a good idea to get that particular Caribe cabin( which normally is the best balcony deck)