only my 2nd cruise, both western carrib. i vote for Cosumel OR Costa Maya .. i don't see a reason for both .. can add a Jamaica stop instead. could not tender at cayman island (too rough .. maybe for senior citizens!) the good points ... had so much fun on the ship that there was little time for pics! very interesting people at our dinner table! we had THE BEST! i have read comments on not spending more for a better cabin .. we had a cat. B (8512) .. we brought wine to the room, ordered cheese and munchie trays from room service ... the fellow shipmates we met and invited to our room really enjoyed it, as we did! 7 days was too long, as i had too much fun and i really missed my pups back home! my suggestion: do it !!!
Glad you had a fun time. We did too on the 3/9 sailing. Respectfully, cannot agree re Jamaica--Been there, done that many times, yrs ago when yo could actually get around the island a bit.. One main reaon we chose this ship to do this itin. was it DID NOT do Jamaica. There was lots to do in Coz. & Costa Maya either on own or excusions...liked them both. Sorry yo umissed Gr Cayman it was the best port...just a lovely place even if driving is on opp. side & it is the home of the $25.00 tee shirt! We could've cruised on with Enchantment for a few more days even a back to back !