I sailed on the Serenade this past January, and the cheapest I could find airfare from Indianapolis was for $400 on ATA. That is the only drawback to sailing out of SanJuan. Also if you check on Cruise.com, they show an E1 category room to cost $2294, but then they give you a $160 online booking discount . Fare is $2134. They have some rooms on deck 10 available, but I would avoid booking the rooms they show on deck 7. The rooms on deck 7 that they show have funny shaped and small balconies. One of the people in our group stayed in them, and I feel they got a little jipped.