Folks you are welcome to discuss and disagree all you want here. HOWEVER, once it turns to personal attacks, you're violating the CruiseMates User Agreement.... and your posts will be deleted
It should be NOTED that people on the same ship can have totally different experiences. Doesn't make one right and the other one wrong. Often people's expectations, and possibly lack of research before the cruise affect their experience as well.
On my sailing I had good friends who had early seating at a table for two, we had late seating. They reported excellent service, while ours suffered some. I couldn't tell them they were wrong..... they experienced it, and were quite happy with it![/b]