Have to agree with Norm again...food is such a personal thing...can't tell you how many times I've read on this CruiseMate's board, where some just can praise enough Celebrity's food, others hate RCCI's and then there are those swearing that HAL's cuisine is just plain bland.
It's really a matter of personal taste. We've been on all the above and have found plus and minuses on all the ships.
We've actually enjoyed all of them for different reasons. Only one time did we have a serious complaint, and that was on RCCI Radiance of the Seas. The food in the Buffet was extremely salty. THAT has been our only serious complaint in 6 cruises.
Actually, we think that the cruiselines do pretty well overall providing interesting well presented meals. And they even offer healthy alterative meals for those of us silly enough to want to diet on a cruise -