I'm with you Rob, I LOVED the chocolate melting cake, had it every night. My June 23rd cruise on the Liberty is almost here, my mouth is watering already. If I close my eyes I can taste that warm, gooey chocolate center, heavenly!! I'll have a couple for you.
As far as dining room food, I think some people who haven't sailed on Carnival recently would be pleasantly surprised at the improvement in the quality of the food served in the formal dining room. At least Carnival has hot, fresh rolls at dinner. You could kill someone with RCCL's cold, stale rolls.
Now, if Carnival would only stock dark beer, I'd be a happy woman.