CruiseMates Cruise Community and Forums

CruiseMates Cruise Community and Forums (
-   Carnival Cruise Lines (
-   -   salt water pools on carnival (

Patticake November 2nd, 2004 10:00 AM

salt water pools on carnival
i know i haave read this before, but it seems to be more of a deciding factor than i thought. we already are booked on carnival, victory in july of 2005 with five adults and four kids. i noticed princesses pools are fresh water. is the salt water a real deterrent in enjoying the pools and water slide on the victory.? do the kids have a really hard time with burning of the eyes from the salt.? i assume our grandchildren 5,8,11, and 12. will be spending a lot of time int he pools on at sea days. we are doing snorkeling excursions on two islands so they will be in salt water on all those days and dealing with it. does anyone know the reason princess has freshwater and carnival has not mastered this yet? i know we are going to have a wonderful time either way and are all really looking forward to this. it was just a question on my part as i never thought about this particular situation. patticake

sdreger November 2nd, 2004 10:20 AM

Re: salt water pools on carnival
Hi, we are just off the Glory (ok two weeks ago) and the salt water was no more of a problem than a highly chlorinated pool. My son wore goggles most of the time that we bought on our way to the cruise ship for about $3 and they worked just fine. They also have fresh-water showers right next to the pools for rinsing. The biggest problem I noticed was remembering to keep your mouth closed, that was kind of icky. But, still, it's no different than swimming in the ocean, except no fish.


Darcy November 2nd, 2004 11:22 AM

Re: salt water pools on carnival
We were on the Inspiration in 2004 and my son (10) practically lived in the pool on sea days. No complaints or adverse effects. The girls (12 & 15) both went in just not as much as my son. Neither of them had any complaints either.

Rie November 2nd, 2004 02:27 PM

Re: salt water pools on carnival
I personally love the salt water pools because they don't burn my eyes like the clorinated ones do. They also don't have that strong bleach smell to them.
Just a suggestion to pass on. ... hold your nose before you hit bottom on the slides.

hunkalove November 2nd, 2004 04:56 PM

Re: salt water pools on carnival
The reason Carnival and most other lines have saltwater pools is that it is more environmentally friendly and safer. Chlorine is a toxic and dangerous chemical - that's why your eyes actually burn more in a chlorinated pool rather than the ocean. A few new resort hotels have been built with saline pools instead of chlorinated pools for this reason. Also, chlorine in water (either in chlorinated pools or in chlorinated tap water) has been linked to skin cancer.
The other thing with saltwater pools is that the ships can drain the water and get fresh, clean ocean water everyday. A chlorinated pool cannot be drained into the ocean and requires a lot more equipement to keep the water biologically clean.

Dorothy November 2nd, 2004 04:59 PM

Re: salt water pools on carnival
What hunkof said....

It's not that Carnival hasn't *mastered* chlorination, they have actively chosen to use saltwater. I've never found swimming in salt water to be particularly bothersome. Chlorine is MUCH harder on my eyes.

But then again I rarely set foot in the pools on board.


sailgirl November 2nd, 2004 06:23 PM

Re: salt water pools on carnival
No one in our party had any complaints about the salt water. WE usually swim in a chlorine pool but we also like the ocean.

Jim Bragg November 2nd, 2004 06:34 PM

Re: salt water pools on carnival
While the pools are filled with saltwater understand that they still do put in a small amount of clorine to meet sanitary standards. Personally I think the saltwater pools are better as they are cleaned and filled daily as opposed to the freshwater pools.

All times are GMT -4. The time now is 11:20 PM.

Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.6.1