on the 10 day Canada/New England cruise between Montreal and New York? which direction is better? which cruise line/ship? I think I want to spend the night tied up at Quebec, but I'm not really sure why. I do know that Princess, HAL, and at least 1 other line do this itinerary.
I sailed that itinerary on the Princess this fall. We chose Princess over HAL because there was an extra sea day and HAL only had the one day sailing on the Saguenay River (very pretty and not to be missed). I thoroughly enjoyed Quebec and would have liked more time there and Montreal was super, too. I think the longer itinerary is definitely a better deal because Quebec and Montreal are super. I think either direction would be fine and personnally I like Princess but I haven't sailed HAL so I can't say. I think NCL does the longer itinerary, too. Keep reading the boards, check out the itineraries and ships and you'll chose the one best suited for you! Enjoy! Sue P.S. Email me if you have other questions.