This rotating dining experince hands down beats all! It's great to have a new experince every evening, yet your same waitors stay with you. So, the first night you tell'em what you like and they'll do it every night from then on. Hence, if you have a special dietery need...no need to tell someone every night, cause' your servers will already know!
And, for kids this is was an excellent idea, cause they don't sit at the same restaurant every night or even the same table. Keeps them from being as bored at the table then if you were at the same table in the same restaurant every night looking at the same views. Even when the dining room's as nice as say the Mariner of he Seas. I still prefer Disney's experience.