Try the Caribbean Princess!! We sailed on her last October and enjoyed the cruise, staff, food and entertainment so much that we are sailing her again this October. They've added a new venue to the Horizon Court, called Cafe Caribe. If you like seafood, they have unlimited 3-4 times during the week. Sail away party is great, bands are good and the atmosphere is terrific. Try it.......I think you'll like it! This is our 11th cruise on Princess and the CB is our favorite big ship, so far. When are you thinking of sailing?
I'm a medium ship person although I had a great cruise on the Golden. Sailing single, running into some of the people more than once seems easier on a smaller ship.
The newer, bigger ships have more dining options, which don't particularly interest me as I prefer traditional. I may try the Island or Coral some time but doubt that I'd ever go on the Caribbean Princess.
My next cruise, in September, a B2B on the Sea Princess for 21 days, just the right size and I'm sure I'll be very happy!